Shooting the Moon: Should states require the H1N1 vaccine for healthcare workers?

Paris Nourmohammadi, JD; Brigid Ryan, JD

doi:10.5055/jem.2009.0035

Authors

Paris Nourmohammadi, JD
Brigid Ryan, JD

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5055/jem.2009.0035

Keywords:

H1N1, mandatory vaccination, employment, influenza, health care worker

Abstract

On June 11, 2009, the director of the World Health Organization (WHO) raised the phase of alert in the Global Influenza Plan from level five to level six. The cause for this was the H1N1 virus which had already affected several countries. A level five alert is declared when more than one country in a single WHO geographic region is affected by the same virus. A level six declaration means that community outbreaks are occurring in at least two WHO geographic regions. Once such a declaration is made, little time remains before mitigation efforts must be planned and communicated to the public. In the wake of the WHO declaration, policy makers are clamoring for adequate disease mitigation strategies. Some health departments intend to require employees to wear personal protective equipment while on the job. Other state health departments are encouraging employees to stay home sick if they think they might have the flu. The New York State Health Department has issued an order requiring all healthcare workers to be vaccinated for H1N1 or risk being terminated. This article will explore the New York State policy and make recommendations to policy makers about how to prevent the spread of H1N1.

Author Biographies

Paris Nourmohammadi, JD

Law & Policy Analyst, University of Maryland Center for Health and Homeland Security, University of Maryland Baltimore, Baltimore, Maryland.

Brigid Ryan, JD

Law & Policy Analyst, University of Maryland Center for Health and Homeland Security, University of Maryland Baltimore, Baltimore, Maryland.

References

New York State Commissioner of Health Richard F. Daines, MD, and State Hospital Review and Planning Council (SHRPC): 10 NYCRR Subpart 66-3: Health care personnel influenza vaccination requirements. Amending title 10 of the Official Compilation of Codes, Rules, and Regulations of the State of New York. Effective on August 13, 2009.

New York Governor’s Site, Governor David A. Paterson Press Releases: Governor Patterson temporarily suspended the regulation due to a shortage of the H1N1 vaccine. Available at http://www.ny. gov/governor/press/press_1022094.html. Accessed November 2, 2009.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Pandemic influenza resources, FluSurge 2.0. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/flu/tools/ flusurge/. Accessed October 29, 2009.

Levi J, Segal LM, St. Laurent R: Trust for America’s health, H1N1 challenges ahead, Arizona (117%); California (125%); Connecticut (148%); Delaware (203%); Hawaii (143%); Maryland (143%); Massachusetts (110%); Nevada (137%); New Jersey (101%); New York (108%); Oregon (107%); Rhode Island (143%); Vermont (108%);Virginia (100%); and Washington (107%).Available at http:// healthyamericans.org/reports/h1n1/. Accessed October 29, 2009.

Levi J, Segal LM, St. Laurent R: Trust for America’s health, H1N1 challenges ahead, Colorado (88%); Florida (80%); Georgia (78%); Maine (83%); Michigan (79%); New Hampshire (84%); New Mexico (93%); North Carolina (95%); Pennsylvania (77%); South Carolina (93%); Utah (83%); and Wisconsin (75%). Available at http:// healthyamericans.org/reports/ h1n1/. Accessed October 29, 2009.

The Constitution of the United States: Amendment 10.

Mariner W, Annas G, Glantz L: Jacobson v. Massachusetts: It’s not your great-great-grandfather’s public health law. Am J Public Health. 2005; 95: 581-590.

Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11, 1920.

Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S 11, 1920.

Perry v. Sinderman, 408 U.S. 593, 1972.

The Constitution of the United States: Amendment 14.

Cold and Flu Health Center: Is the H1N1 vaccine safe? Available at http://www.webmd.com/cold-and-flu/features/is-theh1n1- swine-flu-vaccine-safe. Accessed October 29, 2009.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): General questions and answers on 2009 H1N1 influenza vaccine safety. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/h1n1flu/vaccination/vaccine_safety_qa.htm. Accessed November 1, 2009.

Geier DA, Geier MR: A meta-analysis epidemiological assessment of neurodevelopmental disorders following vaccines administered from 1994 through 2000 in the United States. Neuro Endocrinol Lett. 2006; 27: 401-413.

Geier DA, Geier MR: An assessment of downward trends in neurodevelopmental disorders in the United States following removal of Thimerosal from childhood vaccines. Med Sci Monit. 2006; 12: CR231-CR239.

Geier DA, Geier MR: An evaluation of the effects of thimerosal on neurodevelopmental disorders reported following DTP and Hib vaccines in comparison to DTPH vaccine in the United States. J Toxicol Environ Health A. 2006; 69: 1481-1495.

Geier DA, Geier MR: Early downward trends in neurodevelopmental disorders following removal of thimerosal-containing vaccines. J Am Phys Surg. 2006; 11: 8-13.

Geier DA, Geier MR: A prospective study of mercury toxicity biomarkers in autistic spectrum disorders. J Toxicol Environ Health A. 2007; 70: 1723-1730.

Young HA, Geier DA, Geier MR: Thimerosal exposure in infants and neurodevelopmental disorders: An assessment of computerized medical records in the Vaccine Safety Datalink. J Neurol Sci. 2008; 271(1–2): 110-118. doi:10.1016/j.jns.2008.04.002. PMID 18482737.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Frequently asked questions about Thimerosal. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/ vaccinesafety/Concerns/Thimerosal/thimerosal_faqs.html#7. Accessed November 15, 2009.

U.S. Food and Drug Administration: Thimerosal in vaccines questions and answers. Available at http://www.fda.gov/Biologics BloodVaccines/Vaccines/QuestionsaboutVaccines/ucm070430.htm. Accessed November 15, 2009.

Institute of Medicine of the National Academies (IOM) Immunization Safety Review Committee; The American Academy of Pediatrics: Immunization safety review: Vaccines and autism. Available at http://www.iom.edu/en/Reports/2004/Immunization- Safety-Review-Vaccines-and-Autism.aspx. Accessed October 29, 2009. Study Fails to Show a Connection Between Thimerosal and Autism. Available at http://www.aap.org/profed/thimaut-may03.htm. Accessed October 29, 2009.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): 2009 H1N1 influenza live, attenuated vaccine: What you need to know. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/pubs/vis/downloads/vis-laiv-h1n1.pdf. Accessed November 1, 2009.

Gunter J: California suspends ban on Thimerosal containing H1N1 vaccine for pregnant women.Available at http://www.examiner. com/x-4079-SF-Sexual-Health-Examiner~y2009m10d23- California-suspends-ban-on-thimerosal-containing-H1N1-vaccinefor- pregnant-women. Accessed November 1, 2009. [General questions and answers on Thimerosal. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/ h1n1flu/vaccination/thimerosal_qa.htm. Accessed November 1, 2009].

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): 2009 H1N1 influenza inactive vaccine: What you need to know. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/pubs/vis/downloads/vis-inact-h1n1.pdf. Accessed November 1, 2009.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC): General questions and answers on Thimerosal. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/ h1n1flu/vaccination/thimerosal_qa.htm. Accessed November 1, 2009.

Schonberger LB, Bregman DJ, Sullivan-Bolyai JZ, et al.: Guillain-Barre syndrome following vaccination in the National Influenza Immunization Program, United States, 1976–1977. Am J Epidemiol. 1979; 110: 105-123.

Roan S: The Los Angeles Times. Swine flu ‘Debacle’ of 1976 is recalled. Available at http://articles.latimes.com/2009/apr/27/science/ sci-swine-history27. Accessed November 1, 2009.

Sencer DJ, Miller JD: Emerging infectious diseases. Reflections on the 1976 Swine Flu Vaccination Program. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/eid/vol12no01/05-1007.htm. Accessed November 1, 2009.

McNeil DG Jr, and Zraick K: The New York Times. New York health care workers resist flu vaccine rule. Available at http:// www.nytimes.com/2009/09/21/nyregion/21vaccine.html. Accessed November 1, 2009.

Towers S, Feng Z: Pandemic H1N1 influenza: Predicting the course of a pandemic and assessing the efficacy of the planned vaccination programme in the Unites States. Available at http:// www.eurosurveillance.org/ViewArticle.aspx?ArticleId=19358. Accessed November 1, 2009.

Hartocollis A, McNeil DG Jr: The New York Times. Areas hit hard by flu in spring see little now.Available at http://www.nytimes. com/2009/10/08/health/08flu.html. Accessed November 2, 2009.

National Vaccine Information Center: Pandemic H1N1 swine flu: What about you & your family? Available at http://www.nvic. org/Vaccines-and-Diseases/H1N1-SWINE-FLU.aspx#preparedness. Accessed November 2, 2009.

The New York State Public Employees Federation: PEF wins temporary restraining order for mandatory vaccines. PEF wins Temporary Restraining Order for Mandated Vaccines released on October 16, 2009. Available at http://www.pef.org/pressreleases.htm# PEF%20Wins%20Temporary%20Restraining%20Order%20For% 20Mandated%20Vaccines. Accessed November 2, 2009.

The New York State Public Employees Federation: PEF wins temporary restraining order for mandated vaccines. Available at http://www.pef.org/pressreleases.htm#PEF%20Wins%20Temporary %20Restraining%20Order%20For%20Mandated%20Vaccines. Accessed November 2, 2009.

The New York State Public Employees Federation: PEF statement on mandated vaccine. PEF Statement on Mandated Vaccination released on September 28, 2009. Available at http://www.pef.org/ pressreleases. htm. Accessed November 2, 2009.

National Eating Disorder Information Centre: Addressing issues of autonomy and beneficence in treatment of eating disorders. Available at http://www.nedic.ca/knowthefacts/documents/ Addressingissuesofautonomyandbeneficence.pdf. Accessed November 2, 2009.

The New York State Public Employees Federation: PEF statement on mandated vaccine. Available at http://www.pef.org/pressreleases. htm. Accessed November 2, 2009.

The New York Times: New York health care workers resist flu vaccine rule.Available at http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/21/nyregion/ 21vaccine.html. Accessed November 2, 2009.

U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: 2009 H1N1 early outbreak and disease characteristics. Available at http://www.cdc. gov/H1N1FLU/surveillanceqa.htm#12. Accessed November 2, 2009.

CNN Health: Obama declares H1N1 emergency. Available at http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/10/24/h1n1.obama/index.html. Accessed November 2, 2009.

ABC News: Swine flu vaccine: Too little, too late? Public officials do their best to stay ahead of the H1N1 virus. Available at http:// abcnews.go.com/Health/SwineFlu/h1n1-vaccine-shortage-frustrationgrows- patients/Story?id=8884346&page=2. Accessed November 2, 2009.

U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: 2009 H1N1 flu U.S. situation update. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/h1n1flu/ updates/us/. Accessed November 2, 2009.

CNN Health: New York suspends mandatory flu shots. Available at http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/10/24/new.york.flu. vaccine/. Accessed November 2, 2009.

Harvard School of Public Health: Survey finds just 40% of adults “absolutely certain” they will get H1N1 vaccine. Available at http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/press-releases/2009-releases/ survey-40-adults-absolutely-certain-h1n1-vaccine.html. Accessed November 2, 2009.

U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: 2009 H1N1 vaccination recommendations. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/ h1n1flu/vaccination/acip.htm. Accessed November 2, 2009.

Maryland Department of Health and Mental Hygiene: Flu preparedness influenza transmission. Available at http://www.dhmh. state.md.us/flu/pdf/InfluenzaTransmission.pdf. Accessed November 2, 2009.